Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Shirt Cuffs and Their Closing


Dress shirts have cuffs of various styles, and though few contemporary cuffs are as noticeable as the ones in the illustration, the style of cuff a man wears says some small thing about him. That is because cuffs are usually chosen to match the formality of an occasion, and deliberately or accidentally adding to or subtracting from the generally accepted formality is a statement of its own.

Shirt cuffs come in three varieties, button, link and hybrid, and each fastens differently. Hybrids, called convertible cuffs, may be closed with buttons or with cufflinks. Being neither fish no fowl, they should be avoided in my opinion and we will say no more about them here.


The least formal contemporary cuff is the button or barrel type that closes with, no surprise, a button or buttons. Ordinary shirts tend to have but a single one of them per cuff, which leaves the wearer with an open cuff if he loses a button, and a slightly misaligned one the rest of the time as the cuff will pivot on one button. Better is the double button cuff in the photograph (one shirtmaker's house style is a three button cuff however this seems to me to be overkill as there is already more than enough buttonning to do each time a man changes his clothes).

Some makers also offer a turnback version of the button cuff, called the cocktail or Bond cuff, that attempts to emulate the look of the linked cuff and, in my opinion, fails to do so.


The more formal link cuff, on the other hand, has buttonholes on both sides that are closed with cufflinks rather than buttons as in the photo above. This is an older form of closing and of course there are a couple of types.

Single cuffs, the original linked cuff, are the standard for white tie and can also be worn with black tie. Plain front white linked cuff dress shirts are also worn with suits by a few aficionados, but never with odd jackets.

The somewhat less formal French, or double, cuff is folded back on itself. French cuffs are are normally worn with suits or black tie. They are usually considered inappropriate with odd jackets.

Now the designs of the links that hold these cuffs vary widely but the principal types are made from either silk or gold. Gold is of course the jewelry version and, as the late Harvey Amies wrote, "If you despise (gold) you had better have just buttons on your shirt cuff." The two gold ends should be joined with a bar or a chain. Most men who think about these things eschew links with only a single finished end because the other side is frankly ugly. Ugly or beautiful, gold links cost from the hundreds to the thousands of dollars.

At the opposite end of the cufflink pricing spectrum is the silk knot, favored by American traditional dressers and others who appreciate their nominal cost. Charvet, the Parisian haberdasher, introduced them about a century ago.

And that is how shirt cuffs are closed.

10 comments:

Matt Spaiser said...

I'm a fan of the cocktail cuff. I don't feel that they try to emulate a linked double cuff but that they're something else on their own. But I understand that they aren't for everyone.

Sam said...

Will,

ALL of my dresshirts are french-cuffed. Does this mean (seriously) that I will be considered an oddball every time I wear those shirts with my odd jackets?

I definitely am not going to discard my french cuff shirts, as I paid too much for them - they are all bespoke.

And I really don't want to spend any more money on shirts that will be identical to the ones I already have, except for having a button cuff rather than french.

Regards,

Sam

levinid said...

Amd what is wrong with silver cuff links?

Ryan said...

Will,
I was wondering if you'd elaborate a bit on the sleeve placket and button. The vast majority of my shirts have no placket button and I have come to prefer the look; I feel it provides a cleaner line. I recently visited a tailor to have some custom shirts made and he looked at me like I was mad when I asked for no button.

What are your thoughts? Many times throughout the day I remove my coat for work and the placket is more visible than it would be if I could just leave my coat on all day.

Davidikus said...

Funnily enough, I posted on cufflinks recently (davidikus: Archives... /In defence of the cufflinks/ & Christian Lacroix) following Some intransigent remarks about cufflinks on Fantastic Man's forums.

I think Hardy Amies's words might be slightly outdated, though. There are perfectly nice cufflinks which are neither golden nor with just one end finished. Older gentlemen also used ribbons to tie their cuffs, especially when wearing a bow tie. If done properly, this is probably the most discreet way to close a shirt.

My favourite cufflinks actually don't have two ends: they are v-shape or stirrups shaped.

seitelman said...

Will, I wear both the three button cuff and the James Bond cuff.

They have been made by that certain, unidenitified shirtmaker on Jermyn Street as well as others here in the USA.

Based on your disapproval, I have consigned them to the shredder.

Horatio said...

It looks like this post has created quite stir--always a good sign.

I understand the reasons for the double-button cuff, but we didn't get your thoughts on placket buttons. May we?

Unlike Ryan, I like the look of placket buttons, but it's a near-moot point for me: I almost always leave my jacket on. The bigger issue is whether or not a shirt should have placket buttons at all, and, if so, whether they belong on a shirt with double-button cuffs (or French cuffs, for that matter). Thoughts, please, Will?

As for Sam, I think patterned shirts with French cuffs can be the day's flair when wearing an odd jacket. I would be hesitant to wear a solid shirt with French cuffs with an odd jacket, and would never wear a contrast collar shirt with an odd jacket.

But that's just me.

Will said...

The placket button is probably not enough to carry a post by itself. Suffice it to say that I have always understood (but never verified) that they were once required for men who were attending the English court, lest the ladies be offended by the sight of some bare male forearm.

Personally, I get them on both button and French cuffed shirts. T&A once made an order of shirts without them and I hate the way the placket gapes on the couple that remain in my wardrobe.

Toni Malminen said...

How about wearing French cuffs with navy blazers? As a navy blazer is a bit more formal than an odd jacket, it seems more appropriate to wear one with a French-cuffed shirt. Or at least that's what I've always thought..

A4 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
 
Blog Widget by LinkWithin